An Unnecessarily Exhaustive Guide To The 2010/11 NCAA Tournament, Part 3: Southeastern Region
March 17th, 2011
There is no better event in the American sports calendar than the NCAA Tournament. None. Zilch. Zero. And it’s not even especially close.
All the games running concurrently, and the one game knockout format, make for captivating evenings of hours and hours of entertainment. This is particularly true of the first round, where action jumps from game to game, and Greg Gumbel struggles to keep up with all the information he’s getting in his ear. It’s like the FA Cup, except it’s better.
Much, much better.
And I like the FA Cup.
Since this post is long enough already, the intro ends here, and there follows a preview (often in the form of a recap) of all 68 of the teams taking part in this, the 2011 NCAA Tournament. In this post: the 17 teams in the Southeast region. Use the following links to skip to relevant parts.
Arkansas-Little Rock – Belmont – Butler – BYU – Florida – Gonzaga – Kansas State – Michigan State – Old Dominion – Pittsburgh – St. John’s – UCLA – UC Santa Barbara – UNC Asheville – Utah State – Wisconsin – Wofford
|Twinned with Little Rock.
The Trojans rely on an 11 man rotation and 4 guards at a time, to harass the opposition and ugly up the game. They pretty much play with five out, moving the ball, looking for threes, or long twos off screens, with little inside game to go to. And since they rank 9th in the nation in three point percentage, it certainly has its merits.
They are led by conference player of the year Solomon Bozeman, the Sun Belt Conference’s own entry level version of Kemba Walker. But there is no real threat here.
Belmont have been subtly touted as a possible upset team by national media for much of the season. They shoot a lot of threes; to reaffirm that, they shoot a LOT of threes. They have made 321 on the season in 34 games, second most in the nation (behind only VMI), and 29 ahead of third place Louisville. Their percentage (.381%) ranks third; their attempts (842) ranks fourth. Junior bigs Mick Hedgepeth and Scott Saunders, standing 6’9 and 6’10 respectively, tidy up the missed ones, while pretty much everyone else casts them up. The Bruins go 12 deep on most nights – sophomore guard Ian Clark averages 12ppg on 42% three point shooting (the most dynamic of the bench), the aforementioned centre duo, two 6’7 underclassmen who shoot some threes (Trevor Noack and Blake Jenkins), one slasher (6’1 sophomore Kerron Johnson, who has more FTA than FGA), senior 6’6 defender and offensive rebounding specialist Jon House…..and then everyone else is a shooter. And a presser.
What they don’t do especially well is rebound. But there’s enough there for some upset potential. It just takes one hot night for that to be enough for an upset. It worked for Northern Iowa.
|The single biggest improvement Matt Howard made this season was not growing one of these again.
Last year’s runners-up barely struggled to be the best team in the Horizon League this season. They eventually won the tournament by beating Milwaukee, but only after going 0-2 to the Panthers during the conference regular season. They returned almost everybody from that team, losing only versatile defensive player Willie Veasley (who turned pro and went to Japan), backup little-things forward Avery Jukes (who hasn’t played professionally), and current Jazz forward Gordon Hayward. But those three losses were enough to severly weaken the team. And it’s mainly because of Hayward.
Put simply, Hayward’s star power was not replaced. Veasley was replaced; athletic hustling defensive-minded senior guard Shawn Vanzant simply stepped into a bigger role, and while he’s smaller than Veasley and has less defensive versatility, he can be disruptive. Jukes was easily replaced; 6’11 sophomore Andrew Smith has gone from not playing at all to being a starter and a key player, an interior finisher, good rebounder and decent passer, whose defensive philosophy of tanding still with his hands up and being whistled for fouls can sometimes be useful. But Hayward? Hayward was not replaced.
Matt Howard has reinvented himself somewhat in his senior season. He retains all his post footwork, touch and toughness, yet to that combination, he has added a three point shot. Howard is 44-99 from three on the season after going 5 for 20 in his previous three seasons, has improved defending the perimeter as well, and is committing less fouls than before. Shelvin Mack is a high quality all-around guard; a shooter, a scorer, a distributor, a leader, a defender, a driver. He can be whatever Butler needs him to be. Ronald Nored brings the defense and the ball handling, and is slightly less terrible as a scorer this season. Freshman forward Khyle Marshall has size, athleticism, toughness and energy, and will be a key player in the future once he learns a jumpshot and gives more consistent defense. Garrett Butcher is also a player for Butler. The rotation is rather long.
But none of them replace Hayward.
Working to Butler’s advantage is that, more than most teams, they crescendoed through the season, and have won their last nine games. Silly losses notwithstanding, Brad Stevens found a rotation that works; this means no Erik Fromm, no Chrishawn Hopkins, less Garrett Butcher. Stevens now has his shooters (Zach Hahn and Chase Stigall) working in tandem, Howard and Mack leading from the front, and Marshall, Smith, Vanzant et al contributing enough. But they’re not what they were last year. And it’s not especially close.
|“B, Y, B-Y-U nimmers. [Jimmer, Jimmer, that nimmer Jimmer.]”
Jimmer Jimmer Jimmer Jimmer Jimmer Jimmer Jimmer Jimmer Jimmer Jimmer Jimmer Jimmer Jimmer Jimmer Jimmer Jimmer Jimmer Jimmer Jimmer Jimmer Jimmer Jimmer Jimmer Jimmer Jimmer Jimmer Jimmer Jimmer Jimmer Jimmer Jimmer.
That serves as both a recap and a preview.
|This has finally gone.
The Gators try play defense at every position. Erving Walker may be small for a point guard, but he’s quick, works hard, and is disruptive; Kenny Boynton may be small for a shooting guard, but he’s quick, works hard, and is disruptive. Chandler Parsons is big for a small forward, and yet he’s quick, works hard and is disruptive. Alex Tyus bounds about with great energy, even he doesn’t have the cliched energy player dreads any more. Vernon Macklin is an immovable object in the middle. And Patric Young, the freshman off the bench, is a future SEC DPOY. He really is, and you can quote me. Florida have always landed good big men, and with Young in the mix, they’re right back at it.
Speaking of big men, Macklin has had a good season, showing the offensive game he never previously did. The fifth year senior now has precisely one move in the post – the right handed hook shot. It works, too. And very very occasionally, he’ll counter it with a lefty one, too. He also provides strong post defense, some shot blocking and good rebounding numbers, alongside God awful free throw shooting, no jumpshot, and absolutely nothing outside of 10 feet on either end. So even with his one move, he’s limited. Tyus is also limited – his threats to transfer to a program that would let him play small forward never amounted to anything. Maybe he realised that it wouldn’t make much sense, given that he could neither dribble nor shoot. As it happens, Tyus takes a few jumpers these days, using an unnecessarily high release with about four redundant movements in it, and they do not go in much. Nevertheless, he is still a capable finisher in the paint, brings his energetic roaming defense, does a valiant job on the interior despite being overmatched physically, and grabs some rebounds.
The Gators’ offense remains perimeter-oriented, led by the good outside shooting and optimistic shot selection of the small backcourt duo of Walker and Boynton. Both are good shooters with about 27 feet of range, but neither is a point guard, despite their body types. They don’t like to pass, or penetrate the lane much, unless it’s in transition. Instead, they pester opponents on defense, get the ball upcourt, and then look to cast up threes. This greatly helps or greatly hinders, depending on whether said shots go in. It therefore benefits Florida that Chandler Parsons is such a willing passer, as someone has to. Parsons is a big point forward, quality defender, good secondary ball handler and useful rebounder with good athleticism, much improved strength, and a much improved jumpshot. God awful free throw shooting aside, Parsons has rounded into a very nice role player, the team leader in both rebounds and assists, also chipping in 12 points per game.
Florida are led by those six, although they can go with as many as ten players at times. When he enters the game, freshman Casey Prather likes to look for threes and long twos, both off the dribble and off of catch-and-shoot situations, without looking to do a whole lot else. He has attempted zero free throws this season. Freshman Frenchman Will Yeguete (6’7, 210) likes to throw himself wildly at the offensive glass, and by my troth, he gets them. Backup point guard Scottie Wilbekin is still only 17 years old, and gets quite a lot of minutes for one so young, having a decent impact defensively. And backup big man Erik Murphy showed up with a three point stroke this year, giving him a fairly reliable offensive tool to go along with his agility, effort and rebounding. He’ll play a much bigger role next season, once Tyus and Macklin have both signed in Israel.
Florida haven’t won a tournament game since their last title season. This season, they’re a number 2 seed, and thus they should breeze the first game against Santa Barbara. But after that is the winner against UCLA and Michigan State. And without wanting to sound too much like Mike Patrick, that’s a tough, tough game.
|Curtis Kelly interrupts Gonzaga’s junior prom night.
Gonzaga invited criticism and problems when they created an incredibly tough non-conference schedule against a host of power conference teams, and then lost almost all of them. At one point, they were trailing St. Mary’s by miles in the WCC rankings, and weren’t even going to get an at-large bid. But they turned it around, tied for the WCC regular season championship, won the tournament, and realised their potential. Just in time.
Part of the reason for the improved play has been the improved health of Elias Harris. Harris is clearly still not back to 100% in his recovery from the Achilles injury that has hampered him all year, but at least he’s not at 50% any more. Harris’s strength is his athleticism – it’s his main asset on offense, defense, and the glass. It’s also what he’s missed this year because of the injury. If asked to just catch-and-shoot, Harris isn’t especially effective; if asked to just create in the post, Harris isn’t that effective. He does a modicum of both, but he needs his athleticism, his abilities to run the court and take slower forwards off the dribble, to realise his offensive potential, and to have much of an impact defensively. He got past people through physical tools more than ball skills, and he’s not been able to do that as much this season. Improving his handle, his lower body strength for post-up situations, and his jumpshot, would all help mitigate that, but it hasn’t happened yet.
The turnaround can perhaps be partially cited to a rotation change. Canadian national team big man Kelly Olynyk – a good rebounder, hustler, extra passer and little things player – began to see less minutes in the front court. In his place came freshman Sam Dower, a monster of a man, with all of two moves to his credit – the trailer three (which he wildly underutilises) and the one drive to the middle lefty hook over the right shoulder (which he used on basically every possession, and which no one can stop, because he’s just too big.) When combined with the offensive skill of finesse centre Robert Sacre – whose footwork is good, whose height is better, and whose turnaround jumpshot is similarly unblockable – Gonzaga could throw a scoring big man option on the floor at all times, which most of the West Coast Conference couldn’t complete. Add Harris to that mix, and mismatches were opening up all over the show.
Senior guard Steven Gray got out to a blisteringly hot start to the season, then cooled down immensely, and now is averaging only about the same as he did as a junior, except now on only 41% shooting. Gray is a good sized, decently athletic guard, with a good jumpshot and some good defensive abilities, but he can’t dribble. This wasn’t a problem when he had Matt Bouldin next to him, but with Bouldin graduated and going to Greece, and Demetri Goodson continuing to offer nothing at point guard, Gray suddenly had to become a primary playmaker, ball handler and creator. And with his lack of handles, he just can’t do that. Gray’s a good passer of the ball, yet without the ability to dribble through much traffic, such a passing skill is inevitably underutilised. Other wing options include German freshman Mathis Monninghoff (who, at this point, offers little more than some hustle and catch-and-shoot abilities), junior college transfer Marquis Carter (who has become a big minutes player for the team, contributing a little bit in all facets of the game, with good efficiency and few mistakes), and Canadian national team member Mangisto Arop (pronounced without the A, and who likes to post up from 25 feet away, which must always be lauded).
The big hole is at point guard, where Goodson continues to struggle greatly. Goodson tries hard defensively and is good in the open floor; in half court situations, though, he just doesn’t help. However, this too was addressed somewhat midseason, when John Stockton’s former walk-on son David was given a chance at the role. David isn’t what John was, and he’s never going to be. But that’s irrelevant. David stabilised the position, and ran the offense better than Goodson has ever done. He does this while being too small to stop anyone getting to any spot defensively, being rather slow, and having little to not shotmaking ability of his own. Sounds familiar, no?
Gonzaga found their rotation throughout the season – less Olynyk, Goodson and Monninghoff; more Stockton, Dower and Carter – and got good contributions from their freshman that offset the struggles of the upperclassmen. They face a tough first game in the second round against St. John’s, the number 6 seed in the region. But for all their upperclassmen and supposed experience, St. John’s don’t have tournament experience. And for all their underclassmen and supposed inexperience, the Zags do. It’s a winnable game.
|Once Will Spradling hits his teens, he’s going to be awesome.
Kansas State were wildly overrated to begin this season, and then promptly disappointed everyone. They struggled out of the game, then struggled worse, and suffered a great deal of midseason player turmoil. And then somehow, they stemmed the tide.
Much of their struggles were attributed to the graduation of Denis Clemente, whose ball handling, speed and slashing gave the Wildcats dimensions they otherwise lacked. Also losses were big man Luis Colon (who couldn’t score, rebound, pass or defend, but who was at least big), and junior wingman Dominique Sutton (whose Adrian Griffin-like performances were much unheralded in light of the Clemente love). Colon graduated and plays professionally in the Puerto Rican BSN, while Sutton transferred to NC Central to be nearer to his family.
Colon was replaced by prematurely balding Florida International transfer Freddy Asprilla, who provided some interior defense and rudimentary post scoring. But Asprilla was never happy as a Wildcat, neither with his role on the team nor his unnecessary shouty coach who thinks he’s a latin Sean Connery, and left the program to play professionally. (Or so he said – he later transferred to Canisius instead.) Backup big man Wally Judge also decided to transfer, and suddenly Kansas State had lost much of the vaulted frontcourt depth that had made them what they were. Further complicating matters was the season Curtis Kelly has been having – suspended on more than one occasion, villified by Connery for his lack of leadership, and not advancing further on the breakout he’d begun to realise down the stretch of last season. Kelly is an athlete, a shotblocker, a rebounder, a much-improved mid-range shooter, occasional post-up presence, a defender and an underrated passer, who on his night puts all that together and looks like an NBA player. The problem is that he’s had about 5 such nights in his career as a Wildcat.
Clemente was even less easily replaced. The initial decision to move Jacob Pullen to point guard didn’t work out, because, despite his size and his defensive effectiveness at the position, Pullen just isn’t a point guard. He is a secondary ball handler at best, and just not a natural passer like that. He’s a scorer. He just is. If he’s to e’er play point guard, it would have to be in the same way that Eddie House does it, and this wasn’t that. (Pullen then suffered the same leadership/suspension problems as Kelly, which didn’t help anybody.) Freshman Will Spradling then got a chance at it, and had some initial success – he shot the ball well, made solid decisions, and took a ton of charges, the best way to defend if you’re a small unathletic guard. But then he hit the freshman wall early, and stopped making said decisions. He has nevertheless again become a big minute player for the team, mainly on account of the fact he’s one of the few good ball handlers and shooters.
A flurry of guard combinations followed; freshman 6’6 combo guard Shane Southwell had some very good moments defensively, but also had a knack for taking shots he couldn’t make, and has been in and out of the rotation all season. The same is true of junior Nick Russell, who had a lengthy run in the team during the middle of the season as El Connery scrambled to find the right combinations, and who played some physical defense, but who never found a niche offensively and struggled to make the wrong decision. The only two guard constants were Martavious Irving and Rodney McGruder, both good defenders with good jumpshots and good athleticism. Indeed, McGruder has managed the rare feat of leading the team in both rebounds (6.0rpg) and three point makes (67, tied with Pullen), which is rarely seen in a 6’3 guard. Shame he can’t dribble.
It also didn’t help that Jamar Samuels has also struggled this season. With all the aforementioned losses, Samuels was expected to take a bigger offensive role, but last year’s hugely effective sixth man has struggled to make any kind of shot this year. Samuels plays very hard on both offense and defense, and it’s this combination of athleticism and aggression that gets him to the basket, lets him be a disruptive presence on defense, and which brings in the rebounds. Yet he’s fouling just as much as ever (3.3 fouls in 24mpg), and shooting only 41% from the field, down from 52% last year. Having to create every shot for himself now is proving a problem for Samuels, who is a finisher, not a creator. All this frontcourt turmoil conspired to create a bigger role for 7’0 freshman Jordan Henriquez-Roberts, who has had some good moments. JHR is not an offensive player, save for some left-handed finishes around the rim and better-than-expected interior passing. But his size, length and good mobility for his size make him a presence defensively, as well as a fairly prolific rebounder. He is easily outmuscled and commits a lot of fouls as a result, but at least he makes fewer mistakes now.
(Are nicknames really so hard to think of that all five of Kentucky, Arizona, Kansas State, Northwestern and Villanova are called the Wildcats? How hard can it be?)
Kansas State turned it around, and enter the tournament on a decent run of form, with an established rotation and all the headaches behind them. There remains, however, one big Achilles heel – free throw shooting. They shoot only .647% as a team, and only three rotation players shoot over 70% from the field; Russell (84%), Spradling (82%) and Pullen (78%). Do you really want the first two taking clutch free throws in tournament games?
|“Iceberg, right ahead!”
Like Kansas State above, for a while, the Spartans didn’t look like they were going to be here. Wildly overrated heading into the season, they suffered some key losses. Before the season, backup shooting guard Chris Allen was kicked off the team for multiple rules violations, eventually landing at Iowa State. Then during the season, backup point guard Korie Lucious was also suspended, and also decided to transfer, also going to Iowa State. The Spartans became so short at guard that former walk-ons Austin Thornton (junior) and Mike Kebler (senior), both unathletic defensive specialists who can’t make shots, are parts of the guard rotation and have been all season. They combine for 3.6 points and 1.2 assists in 21.3 minutes.
Further compounding the problem has been the struggles of team leader Kalin Lucas, who got injured at the end of last season, and who has been noticably hobbled all season. Lucas nevertheless leads the team in scoring, as is the case every year, using his transition ability and use of screens to get open for jumpshots and into the paint, a high IQ undersized scorer that doesn’t have to resort to calling 1-4 sets all the time. Lucas has been stuck on full-on scorer’s mode all season, by design and quite correctly, forgoing point guard play other than to get the ball over halfcourt and start moving it around. He has been effective at doing this, even with the gimpiness, pouring in 17.2 points per game with 39% three point shooting, both very respectable numbers. But perhaps without the injury, he probably could have cracked 20. (Welcome guard relief came in the form of freshman Keith Appling, who was billed initially as a scoring guard, but who quickly emerged as a defensive presence as well. A combination of the tenacious D, plus the 40% three point shooting, plugged a huge gap in the Spartans lineup and went a long way to restoring their season.)
Picking up Lucas’s slack was junior forward Draymond Green, whose versatility is mentioned second only to his name. Green averages 12.3 points, 8.6 rebounds, 4.0 assists, 1.7 steals and 1.2 blocks, leading the two in all of those categories except points, where he is second to Lucas. (Korie Lucious just about pipped him with 4.1 assists, but he no longer counts. In my mind, at least.) Green’s versatility and statistical impact comes in conjunction with the development of his perimeter skills – always a power forward/centre type, the 6’6 Green is having to become the small forward more suited to his frame, and has therefore improved his handle and added a 37% three point shot. His passing vision and decision making are self-evident, and there’s some offense in the post to go along with that jumper. But despite the passing, the rebounding, the strength, the shot and the defensive instincts, Green is just simply rather slow. For all his defensive stats, therefore, he has a problem on that end. Interior players are too big for him, and perimeter guys are too fast, and the 3.3 fouls in 29 minutes per game hint at his problems here. Green impacts the game on the defensive end by floating around and using his smarts to cause turnovers, playing as much help defense as he can, and to good effect. But in any kind of isolation situation, he can be left wanting.
Once again, Durrell Summers has underperformed. After a good tournament showing last season, it looked like he was going to finally break out, but….nope. It just hasn’t helped. He remains the same passive jumpshooter he ever was, limiting himself to two dribbles, standing out on the perimeter, waiting for threes, occasionally getting to the basket off of a curl, and finishing well at the basket when given the opportunity, but otherwise just floating about. He doesn’t even give as much defensive effort as he used to. If he tried hard and maximized his talent, Summers could be Travis Leslie’s best case scenario; a terrifically athletic scoring guard, with finishing ability, jumpshooting, and elite defense. But as it is, he’s a passive role player who can’t dribble and who doesn’t hunt for his shot. It seems silly, yet it is what it is.
Michigan State has struggled to find the right big men combinations this season. 6’10 sophomore Garrick Sherman has been an occasional starter, but he’s unathletic and a mediocre rebounder, who struggles to guard anybody. He is at the least a good passer, who makes his open looks around the basket, so much so that he shoots the odd percentages of 69% from the field and 37% from the foul line. (Is that better or worse than shooting 37% from the field and 69% from the line?) Speaking of terrible free throw shooting, very strong sophomore centre Derrick Nix has almost doubled his percentage, from 27% last season to 53% in this. But it’s about the only thing he’s improved; he is still overweight, clumsy and easily exposed in quicker matchups. Athletic freshman Adreian Payne has had his moments in the paint, but not without a huge amount of mistakes; this leaves 6’8 junior Delvon Roe as the only consistent frontcourt performer. Roe has reinvented himself into a technically precise defensive presence and good rebounder, who contributes some finishes around the rim, if not a whole lot of creating. Worryingly, however, he continues to have knee problems.
Relying upon hobbled upper classmen, underperforming role players, and a big old hole at centre, doth not the formula for a lengthy tournament run make. But with Lucas playing the best ball of his career right now, and showing he could carry the team down the stretch of conference play, it’s possible that he can carry them further still. One win is the target still, but it could easily lead to another.
|The sizes of shorts that the players wear now is ridiculous.
Previous posts have alluded to the strong performance of the Colonial Athletic Conference this season. Often a one bid league, two teams (George Mason and Virginia Commonwealth) were able to score at-large bids out of it this season, and even a couple of teams that didn’t (e.g. Hofstra and Drexel) proved themselves to be very capable. Old Dominion also made it out of the CAA – in fact, they won it, and thus got the automatic tournament bid. They were more than likely making it anyway.
ODU are led by 6’5 guard Kent Bazemore, the CAA’s defensive player of the year, who is a seriously improved player. Formerly a defensive specialist with questionable offensive skills other than a decent pull-up long two point jumpshot, Bazemore has shown considerable offensive improvements, and now, with the departure of Gerald Lee, has become a primary playmaker. Bazemore is second on the team in scoring at 12.5 points per game, is third in steals (2.9apg), and the only reason his 5.0 rebounds ranks a mere fourth on the team is because of just how good of a rebounding team ODU are. Bazemore is athletic, confident, energetic, lefty and smiley, who has considerably improved his handle, three point shot (now up to 37%) and offensive efficiency. He does some of everything for his team, not least of which is his fine perimeter defense, where his good hands and great effort see him average 2.3 steals per game. Maybe one day, he’ll hit his free throws.
Alongside Bazemore, 6’9 Frank Hassell is a phenomenally productive big man, averaging 15.0 points and 9.6 rebounds in only 29 minutes per game. Hassell, exclusively a post player, is a hose on the interior; active, strong, fluid, patient, and athletic. He employs shot fakes and hook shots to finish in the post, has a power game as well as some finesse, will use either hand, and even hits his foul shots. Defensively, he uses the same physical play, athleticism and aggression to record 1.3 blocks per game, an active central part of the Monarch’s zone defense. Hassell turns it over quite a lot and is undersized against upper echelon post players, but he simply gets it done.
The third wheel for ODU is Ben Finney, a 6’5 senior swingman averaging the universally pleasing statline of 9.2 points, 6.3 rebounds, 3.1 assists, 1.3 steals and 0.6 blocks per game. Like Hazell, Finney is a tough, strong defender who absolutely attacks the offensive glass; he is essentially the perimeter equivalent of what Hazell offers on the interior. He is not a good jumpshooter – which does not stop him for trying anyway – and nor is he a ball handler. But when coming off of curls, Finney attacks the basket like he does the glass, and has some success with his strength advantage. If you’re familiar with Delroy James of Rhode Island, Finney’s a bit like that, only slightly shorter, less athletic, but stronger. And in the tournament.
Old Dominion lacks a back for outside shooting, shooting only 32.9% from three on the season. It’s a team unashamedly built on rebounding and defense, calling cards that have gotten them this far. The designated shooter is 6’3 junior guard Trian Iliadis, who spots up for threes without doing much else, other than not making mistakes and going to all his classes. Neither point guard option is much of a shooter – 6’0 senior Darius James handles the ball well, gets the ball over halfcourt, moves it around and plays defense, but is little threat to score, and his backup Marquel De Lancy did not hit a single three in his first two years (nor did he hit a three in a relationship). 6’8 junior Keyon Carter likes to take jumpshots, but they don’t go in a whole lot. The other big man backup – aggressive 6’9 junior Chris Cooper – doesn’t dabble in any of that perimeter stuff, though. Instead, he plays around the basket, further cementing the Monarchs’ rebounding advantage, grabbing almost six of them in roughly 20 minutes a night, recording more of them than points. These are the things ODU does. And it works.
Old Dominion are one of the best defensive teams in the tournament, and are going seriously underrated. It’s not as though they are one of the most – ODU did it with athletes. They can theoretically contain any team as well as any team, if that makes sense. There is athleticism and size here that translates. It shouldn’t have been a surprise when they won their first game last year, and it shouldn’t be one if they do the same this season either.
(It feels weird to agree with Bill Plaschke about something.)
|Gary McGhee, disgusted with himself.
Pittsburgh sit at the top of the nation’s best conference, the clearcut best team in it. They score big, rebound bigger, have defenders at every position, shoot the three, share the ball, and do a little of everything. They are 51st in scoring, 8th in rebounds, 4th in assists, 20th in field goal percentage and 21st in scoring defense, scoring 13.1 points per game more than their opponent. So far this season, they have been the best team in the country. And I say that while picking Ohio State for the title. No, I’m not sure why either.
The Panthers are led by their guard duo of Ashton Gibbs and Brad Wanamaker. The two make for a fairly unique duo, as neither is a pure point guard, nor a pure shooting guard. Indeed, the bigger one (6’4 Wanamaker) plays more like the point guard than the little one (6’2 Gibbs). Offensively, Gibbs is best as a jumpshooter; it doesn’t look like he should be because of how flat his shot is, but he’s always done that, and they go in anyway, so it’s no fluke. He can shoot off the dribble, but does it mainly via off-the-ball movement, knowing how to use screens, and with a quick enough release to take advantage of even the smallest shreds of daylight. Gibbs has had a weird season; he’s scored well and shot extremely well, employing better shot selection and extra-passing, but he’s driven the ball less than ever, and has also eased off on the defensive end for some reason. Of course, it has not held Pittsburgh back.
Meanwhile, the very unique senior Wanamaker has had a fine season. His size allows him to defend either guard spot, which he does with good hands and aplomb while never getting into foul trouble. Offensively, he is good enough to be a primary ball handler, and collapses defense via skill and body control rather than explosion. He does not shoot threes, but he rocks a great mid-range, including pull-ups off the dribble, and hesitation moves to get him to the basket, where he does a decent job of finishing. He leads the team, even if he doesn’t lead it in scoring (Gibbs does). But his next level prospects are affected by his measurements and lack of athleticism.
Starting centre Gary McGhee plays impeccable defense. He is big and strong, has good timing, rotates correctly and quickly, is a great shotblocking force, and even does well when caught up on switches, Kemba Walker gamewinners notwithstanding. McGhee rebounds well and is a lynchpin of the Pittsburgh team on one end of the floor. He offers far less offensively, save for putbacks, tips, and very easy looks created out of opportunity and strength. He doesn’t have good hands, good touch, post moves, a jumper, or an adequate free throw stroke. His only offensive skill is his offensive rebounding; he does it all on defense. But despite being a one-way player, McGhee is a huge component of one of the nation’s very best teams. He may even have next level potential. The league needs another Brian Skinner.
Filling in at the forward spots are 6’5 junior Nasir Robinson, and 6’6 senior Gilbert Brown. Like Wanamaker, Robinson plays a unique game; he has a shooting guard’s height, frame and athleticism, yet he rarely leaves the paint, and any time spent out there usually results in a turnover. Instead, Robinson operates mainly in the mid-range area, where he deflects passes defensively, makes driving layups offensively, hits the glass, very rarely creates down low, fights hard, and makes interior passes. Shooting and dribbling are, it appears, not always a requirement. Brown is more conventional, an incredibly athletic 6’6 small forward with strong similarities to the about-to-be-mentioned D.J. Kennedy. He defends, runs the court, rebounds, passes, and hits his jumpshots, on which he jumps impossibly high. He thrives as a role player, and he is not a featured player on offense.
In lieu of having a conventional point guard in the starting lineup, as described above, junior Travon Woodall fills the role from the bench. He handles the ball, puts some pressure on with his defense, moves it around, keeps turnovers down, and has slightly improved the accuracy of his unnecessarily high arcing jumpshot (although he remains a long way from being a shooter). For backup big man minutes, sophomore Dante Taylor – who looks quite a lot like Master P – comes in to rebound, clog the lane, exude powerful defense and commit hard fouls. On the wing, redshirt freshman Lamar Patterson plays good defense, although the jumpshots he keeps casting up are not going in. That’s about it for depth at the moment, though, as their seventh man is out due to injury. Talib Zanna, the awesome freshman in question, is currently injured, but may return later on if the Panthers make a deep run.
|Gene Keady’s hair is even scarier from the back. Seriously, does he actually think he’s deceiving
people? Or does he just not care? I think he should care more. And maybe dye it grey.
St John’s have the oldest team to have played since the 2007 Spurs. They have 11 seniors on their roster, and 9 in their 10 man rotation, with Steve Lavin receiving (if not seeking) praise for taking a historically successful team, in the doldrums for so long, and turning them around in only his first season.
Leading the pack is 6’2 scoring guard Dwight Hardy, who has had some phenomenal games this season. Hardy is the St. John’s player most able to create his own shot, the one they turn to when they need a basket, the one they go to down the stretch. He is only a decent shooter, but he’s a great scorer, able to get into the paint and finish, despite his small stature, willing to take contact and get to the line. Hardy is a decent defensive player, too, and he has assumed the leadership role and filled the star-power void that the Red Storm have lacked in recent years. He didn’t drag St. John’s here single handedly, but they wouldn’t be here without him.
The same could be said of Justin Brownlee, whose breakout this season has been rather unexpected. Brownlee does a little bit of everything; his combination of size, strength and athleticism makes him a versatile defender, impactful against all kinds of forwards, and a similar story is true of his offense. Brownlee’s a decent shooter from outside, has a good mid-range game, will run in transition, and can make shots around the basket. He sometimes gets too shot-happy, and doesn’t rebound as well as he ought, but when he doesn’t play well, the absence is notable.
Speaking of notable absences, St. John’s will be missing key cog D.J. Kennedy for the tournament after he suffered a season ending knee injury. Kennedy had a decent season as a role player for the Red Storm, playing decent athletic defense, making passes, hitting some jumpshots, rebounding and running the court, contributing in various ways without ever needing (or wanting) to be a go-to player on offense. In his place, Dwayne Polee – the only non-senior in the rotation – will see increased minutes. Polee is reminscent of a younger Kennedy in his style of play, and has had good moments already this season, although he started to struggle once conference play began. Brownlee may also be bumped down to the wing spot more, opening up minutes on the interior for the athletic Justin Burrell (who rebounds well, but never seemed to realise the extent of his physical tools) and Sean Evans (who has bulk instead of speed, and who had a great showing in the Big East tournament after barely playing to begin the season, benched early due to bad decision making and lapse defense).
Despite it all, St John’s have been one of the worst three point shooting teams in the nation this season. A few players chip in a couple; Hardy hits a few, as does Brownlee, Kennedy (pre-injury) and 6’3 guard Paris Horne (who is probably the best shooter of the bunch, as well as thriving as an athlete, defender and part-time rebounder). But there is no shooting there. It’s an exposable flaw. They also lack a true point guard, unless you count Malik Boothe, the squad’s best ball handler and playmaker who nevertheless can’t crack 18mpg, due to the presence of Hardy. And for all their upperclassmen, this current crop of St. John’s players are not exactly experienced at this. That is not to say that they can’t win a game or two, but it does make it harder.
|Reeves Nelson is nothing if not fearless.
After last season’s horror show (in purely relative terms), UCLA have bounced back slightly to make the tournament this season. This has been helped by a decent summer of additions, highlighted by McDonald’s All-American Joshua Smith (who is pretty much the opposite of Josh Smith). Joshua Smith has probably had a few too many McDonalds All-Americans in his time, for he’s about 50lbs overweight. The bulk has its advantage; the man can’t be moved from the spot once he’s got it, and rebounding position is as easy for Smith to obtain as a Macedonian passport is for any speedy mid-major American guard with a fine handle, looking for a lengthy European basketball career. Smith is also surprisingly effective in pick-and-roll situations, and can make some shots around the basket, although the considerable mobility issues make him a fairly hopeless defender. (Smith often comes off the bench for fellow freshman